Peer Review Process

Every research article is reviewed by at least two independent experts under a double-blind model: reviewers do not know the authors' identities, and authors do not know the reviewers' identities. The Editor in Chief makes the final decision on the recommendation of the handling editor and the reviewers.

Stages

  1. Initial screening (about 7 days). The Managing Editor checks scope, template compliance, anonymization, the reporting checklist and a similarity report. Manuscripts that fail may be returned without review.
  2. Editorial assessment. An editor judges the originality, significance and soundness of the design, and may reject the manuscript at this stage.
  3. Double-blind peer review (about 4 weeks). At least two external reviewers with relevant expertise are invited. A third reviewer, or a methodological or statistical reviewer, is added when the first two disagree or when the analysis needs specialist checking.
  4. Decision. The handling editor weighs the reports and recommends one of the outcomes below. The Editor in Chief confirms.
  5. Revision (14 to 30 days). Authors submit a revised manuscript and a point-by-point response to the reviewers. Substantial revisions may be sent back to the reviewers.
  6. Acceptance and production. Accepted manuscripts go through language editing, copyediting, author proofing and publication with a DOI.

The target time from submission to first decision is 8 weeks. Authors can follow progress in their dashboard.

Possible decisions

Decision Meaning
Accept submission Publishable as it stands, apart from copyediting
Revisions required (minor) Small changes, checked by the editor
Resubmit for review (major) Substantial changes, re-reviewed
Decline submission Not suitable for the journal

What reviewers assess

  • Originality and contribution to theory, measurement or practice in psychological empowerment
  • Clarity of the research question and fit between question, design, analysis and conclusions
  • Adequacy of the sample, measures and procedure, and the validity of the inferences drawn
  • Correctness and completeness of the statistics, effect sizes, reliability and assumptions, or the rigour of the qualitative analysis
  • Command of the relevant literature, and the quality of writing, tables and figures
  • Compliance with research ethics, the reporting guideline and the journal's citation style

Reviewer selection and conduct

  • Reviewers are chosen for subject or methods expertise, hold a doctorate or equivalent standing, and have no conflict of interest with the authors. Reviewers from the authors' own institution are not used.
  • Reviewers keep manuscripts confidential, do not use unpublished material for their own work, and report any conflict of interest or suspected misconduct to the editor.
  • Reviewers are asked to return a report within 3 to 4 weeks and to give constructive, specific comments.
  • Reviewers are acknowledged by name once a year in a list, without linking them to specific manuscripts.

Editors' own submissions

Submissions from the Editor in Chief, a member of the Editorial Board or any editor are handled by an independent editor, and the author is excluded from every stage of the decision. These articles go through the same double-blind review.

Appeals and complaints

Authors may appeal a decision once, in writing, with a clear explanation of the grounds. The appeal is considered by an editor who was not involved in the original decision, and the outcome is final. Complaints about the process are handled under the Publication Ethics policy.