Publication Ethics
Islamic Theology & Practice follows the principles of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) and its Core Practices. Editors, reviewers and authors are all expected to meet the standards below.
Duties of editors
- Judge manuscripts only on their academic merit, free from bias based on the authors' gender, ethnicity, nationality, religious school or institution.
- Keep submissions and reviewer identities confidential, and disclose nothing to anyone other than the authors, reviewers and publisher.
- Declare and avoid conflicts of interest; hand a manuscript to another editor when the conflict cannot be removed.
- Act on credible reports of misconduct, and keep the editorial decision independent of commercial or political interests.
- Publish corrections, clarifications, expressions of concern and retractions when needed.
Duties of reviewers
- Review only manuscripts within their expertise, and decline when they cannot be objective or meet the deadline.
- Treat the manuscript as confidential and do not use its content before publication.
- Give a fair, specific and respectful report, and support criticism with reasons.
- Point out relevant published work that the authors have not cited, and report any substantial similarity with other work.
Duties of authors
- Present an accurate account of the research and its significance, with enough detail for others to check or build on the work.
- Submit only original work, cite all sources fairly, and do not submit the same work to more than one journal at a time. Duplicate or redundant publication and "salami slicing" are not accepted.
- Do not fabricate, falsify or selectively report data or sources, and do not manipulate images.
- Limit authorship to those who made a substantial contribution, and ensure that all of them have approved the final version. Changes to the author list after submission need a written request signed by all authors.
- Obtain ethical clearance and informed consent for research with human participants, protect their privacy, and report the approval in the manuscript.
- Disclose funding and any financial or personal conflict of interest.
- Avoid excessive self-citation and citation manipulation, including coercive or reciprocal citation arrangements.
- Notify the editors at once when a significant error is found in a published work, and cooperate in correcting or retracting it.
Research on religion
Authors should treat the beliefs of communities studied with respect and accuracy. Articles that incite hatred or violence, or that defame persons or groups, will not be published. Critical scholarly discussion of doctrine, schools and institutions is welcome when it is argued with evidence.
Use of AI tools
Generative AI cannot be an author. Authors must disclose AI use in the Declarations and take full responsibility for accuracy, citations and originality. Reviewers and editors must not upload confidential manuscripts to public AI tools.
Handling allegations of misconduct
- Concerns are sent to the Editor in Chief by email or through the Contact page, with supporting evidence.
- The editor team reviews the evidence following the relevant COPE flowchart and, where needed, asks the authors for an explanation within 14 days.
- If misconduct is confirmed, the journal may reject the manuscript, publish a correction or retraction notice, inform the authors' institution or funder, and decline later submissions from the authors.
- Retracted articles remain online, clearly marked as retracted, with the reason stated.
Complaints and appeals
Complaints about editorial decisions or conduct are handled by an editor who was not involved in the case. A written response is given within 30 days.