Plagiarism Policy
The journal does not tolerate plagiarism in any form. Every submission is checked with similarity software (Turnitin or iThenticate) before it enters peer review, and again before publication when the text has changed substantially.
What counts as plagiarism
- Copying words, ideas, data, translations or arguments from another author without credit, including from classical or Arabic sources and from non-English scholarship
- Paraphrasing too closely to the source, or patchwriting
- Self-plagiarism: reusing one's own published text, thesis or dissertation chapters without disclosure and citation
- Duplicate or redundant submission of the same work
- Presenting text or analysis produced by generative AI as one's own, or without disclosure
Similarity thresholds
The report is read by an editor, not judged by a number alone. Direct quotations of the Qur'an and hadith, properly quoted passages and the reference list are excluded from interpretation.
| Overall similarity | Single source | Action |
|---|---|---|
| Up to 20% | Up to 5% | Proceeds to review |
| 21% to 30%, or a single source above 5% | Returned to the authors for revision and resubmission | |
| Above 30%, or clear text copying | Rejected; authors may be barred from submitting for a period |
If plagiarism is found
- Before publication: the manuscript is rejected, and the authors' institution may be informed in serious cases.
- After publication: the journal follows the COPE flowchart, asks the authors to respond, and publishes a correction or retraction notice that states the reason.
- The editors may inform the authors' institution or funder and decline future submissions.
Authors who believe an article in the journal plagiarizes their work can write to the Editor in Chief with evidence.