Collective Empowerment through Participatory Action Research in Marginalised Communities: A Systematic Review and Thematic Synthesis
Keywords:
collective empowerment, participatory action research, critical consciousness, policy engagement, systematic review, thematic synthesisAbstract
Empowerment research has long privileged the individual level, yet marginalised communities frequently pursue change through collective agency, and participatory action research is widely promoted as a means of fostering it. Evidence on how participatory processes generate collective empowerment, and on whether such empowerment translates into social inclusion and policy influence, nonetheless remains dispersed across community psychology, public health and urban studies. This systematic review and thematic synthesis addressed that gap. Four international databases and a national Indonesian index were searched for empirical studies published between 1995 and 2026, and sixteen studies conducted in North America, Europe, Africa and Asia met the inclusion criteria. Methodological quality was appraised with established checklists, findings were synthesised thematically, and confidence in each review finding was assessed. Four interrelated processes of collective empowerment were identified: critical consciousness-raising, collective competence-building, relational trust and solidarity, and institutional access. Their translation into outcomes was conditioned by gendered participation, material and tenure insecurity, the ambivalent role of local intermediaries, political opportunity and the continuity of facilitation. Across the corpus, participatory processes reliably widened access to decision-making arenas and frequently secured formal recognition of community priorities, but evidence of sustained influence over implementation and resource allocation was scarce, and studies from Southeast Asia were notably few. The review advances a process-oriented framework that distinguishes access, recognition and influence over implementation, and it offers guidance for researchers, practitioners and local governments seeking to support durable community-led change.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2026 Laily Hidayati, Herfin Fahri, Muhammad Aziz

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.